Wednesday, April 16, 2014

Math Blog

Prompt: Can we know if mathematics is invented or discovered?

Renato Curiati
Block 4

Mathematics is a subject we learn in school as it being “set in stone”, this is, we assume that it was invented. The teacher goes to the board, explains the rules with examples, and we have homework for the next class. Every single math class is the same. We use variables, symbols, numbers, syntax, and various other forms to solve a problem or expression. And most importantly, we use math to communicate with each other, and it is considered a language. The social interaction is key to the understanding of mathematics, which is an interesting thing.
On the other hand, one might argue that mathematics is discovered. In our number system, we use base ten, which is what we learn in school. But according to the presentation Mr. Fertig showed us, there are numerous ways we can count. If we use base 4, 3x3 is 21, since there are two two’s and one four, which becomes 21. Now, when we see that we think: “No way! 3x3 is 9!”. But that’s what we learned, but not necessarily what is the only correct answer. Also, when we say: 1 + 1= 2, there are other ways to use 1 +1. In binary numbers (computer numbers), 1 + 1= 10. And again, our brain sees it and completely rejects it.  We learn since we are little that 1 + 1 is always true. But as Mr. Fertig told us, 1 + 1 is not always true, and this makes us insane! We see it as something incorrect, but other societies might use it and see the base 10 we use as incorrect. It is all about perception and schema. Each culture uses its own form of counting to fulfill its needs. We may use base 10, but another culture might use base 4 because it is easier for them to count and communicate with each other.
      But what we don’t learn in school is whether mathematics is invented or discovered. As many historians say, the cave men invented math a while ago, as they used rocks and drew on the caves to count and communicate. But this is what our schema tells us, and what we perceive. To what extent can we rely on our schema and our perception? What if math was discovered, and we don’t notice it because our schema says it was invented? How can we know it after all? To what extent can we trust historians? All of these questions are really hard to answer, and this is what makes this question even harder. There is not enough information on either side for us to be 100% sure if math was really invented or was it already meant to be discovered.

To conclude, both arguments are correct, but I personally think that if I had to choose an answer, I would choose that mathematics is discovered. The example of the different bases proves to some extent that there are different ways to count and still reach the correct answer. Even though our schema tells us that the correct way is using base 10, if we use base 4, it is still correct according to its theories and rules. Each culture uses a different form of counting based on their needs. We use base 10 because we have 10 fingers (most of us), and this makes it easier to learn when little. But that doesn’t mean that it is the only correct way of counting. There is no such thing as the “only one”. And us, as human beings, have to respect each culture’s decisions. We shouldn’t see the other cultures as they are wrong, but as another way to count or solve a math problem.

Math Blog

Is Math invented or discovered?

Mathematics is the science of number, quantity, and space.
Math can be either studied in its own right (known to be pure mathematics), or
it can be applied in various disciplines such as physics and engineering. Math
is fundamental for our knowledge system. It is basically what we use to
describe everything that surrounds us: the length of the chair that you sit on,
the weight of your index finger, etc… This is crucial for our society. Many
people say that math itself is discovered. However, what we know is that we
invented our type of math to perfectly suit the human world. The language
itself was invented. For example, we use algebraic language to solve math
problems, which was invented by the Arabs. However, different cultures
established different forms of math based on their own needs. A famous Einstein
quotes resumes everything about our math: “How can it be mathematics, being
after all a product of human thought which is independence of experience, it so
admirably appropriate to objects of reality?” What Einstein means is, for
example, if the universe disappeared, our math would not serve for anything,
meaning another “form” of math would fit better in the “new world”. Let’s take
the different bases, for example. We use the common base, known as base 10. Other
societies use base 4, or even base 2. It all depends on the form of math used.
Just like any other language, math was invented itself. Just like the
cosmologist Max Tegmark said, math is indeed a human discovery and the
universe is essentially one gigantic mathematical object. In other words,
mathematics describes no more the universe than atoms describe the objects they
compose. Math is the universe.
Another example is that an ancient civilization in the Andes
used strings to count, and, therefore, used a completely different math system.
For them, 1+1 would not necessarily equal to two. However, in our math system,
there is no way that this is wrong. This just shows how different cultures
establish math based on their own needs. This Andes population would never say
that 10 times 35 is 350, since they count based on strings, and they might not
even have 350 strings in their system. They might have 10, so they consider
everything past 10 as infinite. Our infinite is different, and so it goes on
and on and on. However, what can be told as well is that our math is invented,
but the relationship between the numbers is discovered, and, therefore, proven
to exist. A perfect example is Fermat’s theorem. Before, we only knew that it
was true, and it perfectly suited our world (we could apply any number in the
equation that the result would be right). However, Andrew Wiles, a famous
mathematician, proved the opposite. He proved that this theory is not true.
This just shows how the relationship of the numbers is discovered. Wiles took a
long time to prove it, but he “discovered” the relationship of the different
numbers that could be used in the Fermat theorem. There are some examples,
however, that are the opposite. For example, Godel’s first theorem (X=X) is
something that we assume it is true, and that this was actually discovered.
However, we can’t prove that it is true. This is the beauty of math. Sometimes
we encounter problems that are important to solve, and we only want to “discover”
the right answer, but when we look at it again, we can’t prove that what we
did. I know that this did not happen to Wiles, but he is an exception. To sum everything
up, the math system itself is invented, but the relationship between the
numbers is actually proven and, therefore, discovered.

Has it always been there?

2) Can we know if mathematics is invented or discovered?

The question above is a quintessential concept surrounding mankind and its relation to the study of mathematics. Nobody ever honestly asks if math was discovered or invented. We may question theories or aspects of absolutely any other area of knowledge doubt the judgements or assumptions they make, but have discussions and doubt the validity of math? That is an unfathomable concept. Or is it?


Humans have developed throughout history on a basis of mathematical discoveries and revelations, using these to their advantage in advances in all other fields. Mathematics has served as a foundation for this progress. However, a question arises of whether mathematics has always been present on earth, waiting to be discovered or if we in fact as a species have created it and all its derivatives. The amount of theorems, conjectures, proofs, numbers and topics surrounding math are countless, however a vital point comes up. Mathematicians on a daily base struggle and search to find new connections and proofs to problems in their area of math. As we watched in the film "The Proof," Andrew Wiles, math professor at Princeton, spent several years in the search for the answer to Fermat's last theorem. After several obstacles and even a thought-to-be solution, problems continued to arise until he successfully worked them out and found a working proof to the theorem formulated centuries ago. The issue here is whether there was truly only one proof that could work, or if he, using his previous knowledge of certain areas math, led himself to an answer. Andrew followed certain paths and options to arrive at his destination. Could it be though, that using this knowledge, he created a connection between those conjectures and a solution to the theorem? We must consider that it is possible that there were hundreds maybe thousands of solutions to that one problem that could be reached through different approaches or paths. Furthermore, it is believed that Fermat himself actually had a proof for his theorem however it was too big to fit in the margin of his book. Andrew's proof was an extensive 200 pages long. Once again, assuming Fermat was being truthful, this proves that Fermat had a substantially simpler and smaller proof using mathematics and resources in his time, while Andrew's was based completely on 21st century discoveries, therefore they could not have been the same. However, there is still the possibility that there were few theories, these two being included. Fermat could also have made some grave error in his calculations, hence the fact that maybe the proof was always there and it was only Andrew that was finally able to decipher it. 

The reason this question is so puzzling and mind-racking is that society as a whole always takes math as the complete truth. In school it is the one class where there is ALWAYS one definite answer, and everything else is practically: wrong. As opposed to sciences or humanities which are much more subjective and prone to discussion, math is in a sense always exact and precise. There are many pieces of evidence, such as the one above, to prove otherwise. We take many basic math concepts, things we learn very young, to be completely correct and build all our other learnings and understandings of the subject around it. By the presentation given by Mr. Fertig during one of our class sessions, some basic principles or statements that we all believed to be correct and unalienable, were very quickly disproved and invalidated. We experienced the simple statement 1 = 0.9999... be proven in less than 5 steps. Using the basic principles of variables and manipulations of equations, and assuming no advanced math trickery was in place, the simple algebra we were taught throughout elementary school was used to prove to us something we knew for a fact could not be true. This led to an astounding discovery that either the statement was false, which we knew could not be true because it was proven, which forced us to believe that in fact there was a flaw in the algebra that we along with the rest of mankind had and was currently using was skewed. This lead me to believe even more that mathematics was actually created, that we find patterns and suit them and adapt them with rules to fit our needs our desired ends, and not that they are waiting to be discovered. 

There is no doubt that they are essential to mankind, but the constant news of mathematical discoveries could in truth be more of mathematical connections, and one more person using their knowledge etc. to connect or create these connections and proofs. 

Mathematics: Invention or Discovery?

Can we know if mathematics is invented or discovered?

In history, archeologists dig up artifacts and sweep off the dust of prehistoric skulls that uncover new civilizations. In science, medicines are found and improved every day that find cures to fatal diseases. In English we decode symbols in classic literature crafted by amazing writers and in art we decipher the meaning of seemingly ambiguous pieces created by the hands of artists. All of our subject areas seem to have been created, and later analyzed, by humans. Artisans, craftsmen, rulers, writers, doctors, scholars, etc. All of them clearly create their craft. But what about mathematicians and this clean, error-free subject of mathematics. Math seems to be the only subject that hasn't been created, it was discovered, through historical tracing, in ancient civilizations such as the Ancient Egyptians and Greeks. But how do we actually know If math was actually there before humans started to use it. Is math a natural thing, and how can we find out if it is? Unfortunately, this is one of the hardest questions to ask because first of all, we cannot go back thousands of years in a time travel device and simply ask civilizations where they first came upon math and second, if math existed before humans, who can we ask? Furthermore, if mathematics was discovered, this means that it was a natural process of the Earth. It means that even before life forms existed, math was there. 

If we look at how math could have been invented, especially in western culture, it would explain the way children and adults use their numbers as opposed to babies. Babies seem to count in logarithms and so for them, exactly half of 9 would be 3 instead of our 5. It is quite interesting to note that our conventional schools teach  us how to count in a base ten system, teach us the man made concept of decimals and whatnot and then later, after our brains have been rewired to think of numbers in a certain way, we are taught logarithms once again. Furthermore, the concept of counting. In my opinion, counting is something that is somewhat vital in all civilizations. Humans use a base of 10 because we have 10 fingers, and of course, 10 toes. But, this base is only a product of human creation. If we were all created with 6 fingers on each hand, maybe we would use base 12. Also, if we look even further, numbers themselves are a human creation. If I placed two pencils in front of me, there would not be two pencils in front of me. There would just be pencils that represented the concept of twoness. Numbers didn't exist until we made them exist. 

Now, if mathematics was discovered, we would have to look back to the origins of the universe. For example, the Big Bang theory that proposes the creation of the Milky Way Galaxy. Was math used to create this phenomenon, or do we just use math to describe it? My assumption is the latter. If math was used to created everything in our universe, wouldn't everything just be perfectly symmetrical, orderly and structured? I just can't see how something as organic and ambiguous as space being mathematically calculated, and if it was, I can't see it being naturally configured. However, there is math in nature. For instance, we can see golden rations in plants and mathematical explanations for hurricanes and other natural disasters. Also, we can see nature colliding with math with Fibonacci's numbers, originally studied on the how fast bunnies could breed in an ideal circumstance. And so, we can see math as a natural thing that occurs within natural environments, but still, humans created math out of these circumstances. There is no way of really knowing that mathematicians did not create math to fit these natural situations. I think this is where I stand at the moment. Although I try to see the argument that math was discovered, it keeps coming back to me seeing how humans created this math. It is actually quite a shocking realization because if math was created, it makes the whole subject so subjective. It is almost like a religion. There are rules that people have made up because those are their morals and values and then people follow them because they also believe these rules are right. The problem is that if these rules are wrong, does that mean that all of the math we have ever done, since the beginning of time, is wrong? How can we justify a system that was created by the people who use it. What if mathematicians really had no idea what they were doing and just made equations because they sounded right and it made all of the puzzle pieces fit together. Honestly, this is a scary thought; to realize that everything you thought was concrete, suddenly isn't; to realize that a subject that is seemingly so full of certainty and so empty of errors may be complete nonsense. 

I believe in math like a religion. I follow the rules because if I didn't my math would not make sense to anyone else. I have realized that it is more of a subjective concept rater than a concrete subject. Math may have been there when the universe was created and maybe the universe has its own mathematical calculation about everything that goes on inside of it. Maybe humans discovered this math, decoded it and built upon it. But maybe, mathematics is just like faith, with rules and concepts mathematicians made up because they seemed to make sense in their own heads. Maybe math is purely conceptual. Maybe, just maybe we are all just following a system of nonsensical numbers. 

What kind of truth does mathematical knowledge offer?

There are three different to test for truth on knowledge claims.
1) Coherence test, which checks if everything works together without any contradictions. You use your own personal knowledge to check if it works. "You have to think"
2) Correspondence test, you examine what happens in the world and relate it back to the truth that you are trying to check. You have to look carefully at the language and then go look for the answer yourself or look at what others might have come up with. "You have to go and check"
3) Pragmatic test. You have to look at the knowledge in which it could be used in practice and estimate if it applies or not. "You have to ask yourself if it works"
Sometimes we use our own experiences to know if something is true or not. We find out if we can accept a certain truth or not. Sometimes people speak of "truth-for-me" this is a concept in which you think something to be true but another person doesn't accept it and consider it to be true. Therefore it is only true for ourselves and it is the same as a belief.

A mathematical truth offers knowledge if you can actually prove that true to be true. But sometimes mathematical truths might not give you the knowledge that you were hoping for but just a formula to which you will never have an answer. For example in math when you say something is equal to something else by using this symbol = this automatically shows to another person reading the problem that something is = to something else and so this must be true. Then using a known formula you try to find the answer to the certain problem.
Another example of a mathematical truth is Andrew Wiles, he believed a theorem to be true but in order to demonstrate that the to the world and have people believe him he had to come up with a proof for this truth. As he worked for it for a very long time and really believed in the certainty that this theorem was true he finally came up with a proof that was correct and was able to call this theorem: true.

One of the ways that you can know if mathematical knowledge is by looking at the mathematical language. Mathematical language is said to be something that is always true. With the theorems and proofs that are made for each problem, people rely greatly on mathematics.
A mathematical truth is said to be: "Most often used to mean in accord with fact or reality, or fidelity to an original or to a standard or ideal. The commonly understood opposite of truth is falsehood, which, correspondingly, can also take on a logical, factual or ethical meaning." And a mathematical language is: "The system used by mathematicians to communicate mathematical ideas among themselves." So does that mean that others who aren't mathematicians can't use this language or don't understand it? To speak the mathematical language you have to be able to understand the different registers of the language, it is something, like every other language, that you have to learn. So when we talk about the truth given by the mathematical language i don't think that this is something that everyone can comprehend. The mathematicians between them when they talk they understand each other because they have specific words and terms that they use to explain what they want to say. If you don't know these terms and don't understand them how can you know if what they are saying is true?
Then again, when mathematicians make proofs to make a certain mathematical statement correct there are always other mathematicians that come after that try to make their proof true so how can you truly know when something is true or not.

So in conclusion, I think I would say that mathematical knowledge gives you truth to some extent. If you have proofs to prove that a certain mathematical equation is true or if you do all the truth checks than you can say that it is true. But even after all those truth checks how can you know if something is completely true? Won't there always be little things keeping us from getting to a pure truth? Sometimes in math you just have to trust the formulas and the givens and you have to believe that in the world that we live in today this is what is true.

Saturday, April 12, 2014

Can we know if mathematics is invented or discovered?

The foundations of mathematics have often been put into question. In spite of its numerous applications to the real world, mathematicians such as Russel and Godel have mathematically proven that... not everything can be mathematically proven. Russel's paradox is one impossible to be solved through logic, where a set of sets that are not parts of themselves will only be part of itself it if isin't part of itself. Godel's incompleteness theorem proved how mathematical systems can either be complete and inconsistent or consistent and incomplete. They cannot prove their own existence. Could the universe have created an imperfect system?

 Socrates' entire cave analogy is based on the notion that those in the cave are unable to conceive “mathness” until they actually see it for themselves. This uncertainty is not a flaw in the idea of realism, it is part of its definition. Fictionalists, on the other hand, because of this uncertainty, argue that math is a method to describe our surroundings rather than a truth. But while they can refer to Bertrand Russel’s teapot analogy as an argument against realism, it also works the other way around. Think of two opposites, realism and fictionalism. Because there is no way to disprove the former, there is also no way to disprove the latter. And because the latter, to an extent, also cannot be proven false — this can be because there lacks evidence for the contrary, but we can also take it to a deeper level. Can the brain study itself? How can one prove something does not exist through deduction? The universe is so immense, so diverse, and so complex, (we live in only 4 of 11 dimensions), can one really claim the chupacabra does not exist based on induction and the principles set scientists? A limited perception and understanding of the universe inhibits the achievement of truth, if that concept even exists (does the notion of existence rely on the notion of truth?), and thus, can we trust ourselves to reach a holistic and sound understanding of life, space, and time? — the former cannot be proven to be true. Unless. Unless. UNLESS the idea of realism and fictionalism can exist together at the same time. Can they? Can something be and not be at the same time? Is it some twisted reality like in Quantum physics, where particles are omnipresent? And if math is, as realists claim, would this “isness” or “truth” be consistent and incomplete or complete and inconsistent? Is that even possible?

Let us look at the 8 ways of knowing. Reason, imagination, faith, emotion, language, perception, intuition, and memory. Perception can only take us so far, since math is not perceivable, not empirically. We do not see math, we see its real world applications. Sure, mathematical notation and graphs can help us "visualize" the concepts, but they are still concepts and ideas, nothing tangible. The nature of mathematics is so beyond our senses, relying on them would lead us to inaccurate results. The "How Long is a String" documentary illustrates this perfectly. When measuring anything, the closer we get and the more precise the instrument, the greater the value of the measurement. As we get closer and closer to the string for example, the more ridges and curves appear, and those increase the original measurement. This happens until we reach the atoms that form the string, and if we were to take a ruler and measure the distance around all of them, the string would have a length of infinity. Reasoning has been inconclusive, since it is impossible to prove or disprove the premises math works by, Godel said so. Language, perhaps, can help us better understand math (to what extent is math a language?), but cannot answer our question in its own terms. This leaves us with emotion, imagination, faith, and intuition. Agh. Besides imagination (imaginary numbers, what is their practical function? Mathematics have been forever advancing into stranger ground. Mathematicians debated for years and years the validity of irrational numbers, negative numbers, zero, and infinity. The discovery(?) of irrational numbers, for example, came as an enormous shock to the Pythagorean thinkers back in 5 B.C. This concept was perhaps strange to them as imaginary numbers are to us math students, but think of the implications irrational numbers have had on the development of science and math as we know today. Thus, math requires a lot of imagination, abstraction, and the ability to think outside the box), for Socrates and his fellow realists, math is entirely faith based. One has to believe on the “isness" of “mathness”, somewhere in the universe, even if there lacks any scientific proof for it. Even fictionalists, who believe the contrary, when working with math, are forced to temporarily put their beliefs (or non-beliefs) aside and simply assume the axioms are true. In a society where math is present in almost every field of study, it is impossible to alienate oneself from it, regardless of its existence or non-existence. But does its prominence in human society enough to justify math as being a source of knowledge? We are looking for truth, but what if truth as we perceive it is only a manifestation of “truthness”? Or… can truth be a human invention? How far does it go? 

The nature of mathematics presents us with various challenges. But just as we have done in the perception unit, where it was basically concluded that our senses cannot be trusted, all we can do is move on. The world still spins. The human experience is still worthwhile (at least for now). Math (in computing and technology) has made this blog possible, not to mention this computer, this room, my clothes, even perhaps the music I’m listening to right now. And if this way of knowing works for us, is it acceptable/justifiable to shrug and say “eh, whatever” and move on even when serious doubts of its existence are raised? Does that apply to all ways of knowing? If something works, does the truth it hold become irrelevant? Yes, the TOK course says no, we just had an entire unit on fictionalise and realism in math, but in the end, the quest for “truth" is inevitably put aside for the sake of what is practical, what is comfortable, and our sanity. This goes beyond math to the fields of science, philosophy, and religion (and more). In religion, for example, the truth holds the key for salvation, redemption, immortality, and more. In science, for understanding, development, progress. In math, the potential destruction of the delicate house of cards built over the centuries by thousands of minds. To what extent is truth absolute (the statement “truth is not absolute” contradicts itself), and to what extent does it hold the key to progress, comprehension, existence, or whatever else that has fed humans’ obsession with it? 

Monday, April 7, 2014

Syllogism Analysis - World Cup in Brazil

Any country that is not ready to host a world event by the time it begins should be ashamed.
Brazil is not ready to host the World Cup
Therefore, Brazil should be ashamed.


Brazil hosting the the World Cup in 2014 has been a recurring issue since its announcement in 2006. Brazilians have been arguing how a country that over 16.3 million people live in extreme poverty and 8.7% of the population do not know how to read or write due to the lack of education can host a World Cup that will require billions of reais in investments. People have also been complaining about the corrupt politicians that take advantage of the event and take money into their own pockets instead of investing it in public hospitals and schools. As of now, the World Cup has cost up to 8 billion reais in stadiums and accommodations, and yet the country is still unprepared, lacking public transit and a decent airport.

Having said that, we can see where the idea behind the syllogism comes from. To start off, the first premise states that any country that is not ready to host a world event by the time it begins should be ashamed, however, what we define as being 'ready' is subjective and relative to the person that interprets it. This involves perception as a way of knowing, as through the eyes of a Brazilian citizen, one may say that the country is completely unprepared, however, according to the standards and requirements of FIFA, Brazil is apt to host the World Cup. Having lived in Brazil for my entire life, I know from personal knowledge and experience that the country is not prepared, as there are many other issues to be resolved, for example, the quality of the public tranportation, the amount of acommodations to host everyone, and the stadiums that are not yet ready. There are also several other political issues to be taken care of before the Brazil hosts a World Cup.

The premise also mentions that the 'country' should be ashamed, which can be considered somewhat of a generalization as the country does not represent a small party of people who make the decisions regarding the event. The country reprepesents the entire population, one cannot say that we should be ashamed of ourselves for something we are not responsible for. Nevertheless, that is only in my opinion, one may also argue that the country is represented by the government or maybe even by the higher social class, which brings the idea of language as a way of knowing. Should Brazil be ashamed for not being ready for the World Cup or should we be ashamed for investing billions of dollars in stadiums instead of investing it on education and health conditions for the entire population? Should we be ashamed for not meeting high expectations being a country that soccer is the native sport? Language here plays a great role in questioning this syllogism.

The second premise then states that Brazil is not ready to host the World Cup, which goes back to the idea of perception, as being 'ready' depends on who interprets it. The source of this claim should be questioned, as we do not know from whose perception this is.

The syllogism is valid, as the conclusion follows given from the premises. However, the valdity of its truth can be questioned as there are subjective matters that are taken into consideration.