Tuesday, May 20, 2014

Is Science Progressive?

"Progressive" has two definitions: (1) gradual and continuous, slowly developing over time. (2) liberal, modern, and “enlightened”. We could discuss how this concept varies from culture to culture and how language shapes how we view “progressiveness”ness, but at least from the IB's standpoint, from a modern/western perspective, favoring innovation is viewed as something positive. We want to improve our lives, we want innovation, we want technology. We want more, at least in our western schema. 

Science, unlike math, does not work with strict, unchanging axioms. It seeks to find patterns in nature to synthesize and explain such phenomena. Through math, reason (induction and deduction), observation, and evaluation in the scientific community, scientists formulate theories and laws that simplify everything around us, making it predictable and measurable. What distinguishes science from fields like psychoanalysis or numerology, is its “falsifiability, or refutability, or testability," as Popper put it. According to Karl Popper, what defines a theory as scientific (not true, useful, or precise. Scientific.) is its “risk factor," where every test is an attempt to falsify it. Like Newton’s law of gravitational force, it can be or it can’t be, there is no middle ground. Freud’s theories cannot be deemed as scientific because everything serves as a confirmation. They do not “prohibit" anything from happening, unlike the second law of thermodynamics, where entropy of an isolated system never decreases. If we were to find a single instance where entropy (in an isolated system) actually decreases, then it is completely undone. That’s an enormous “risk factor”. Because we have never found such instance after centuries of study and observation, this law can be deemed as scientific, and perhaps even true (and to some, beautiful or terribly sad). But we are not looking for truth, not right now. Entropy and thermodynamics could be human constructions based on patterns found in random occurrences, making our quest for truth a bit too much to handle at the moment. Back to science. One important aspect of science is its quest to classify and simplify. The periodic table, taxonomy, the new possible periodic table of particles, etc., are part of scientists' attempt to sort all there is in the universe. Kuhn’s theory of scientific revolution helps us visualize this activity. Its as if “science” seeks to build the jigsaw puzzle of the universe by connecting all that we observe and creating patterns through laws and theories. When we notice an anomaly, a piece that just does not fit into the puzzle we are building, we are forced to switch things around until we find a way to successfully incorporate that piece into the puzzle. 

Much like the TOK truth tests, science also has to pass through three tests, the correspondence, coherence, and pragmatic tests. These tests also indicate the very purpose of science, which would be to correctly categorize/classify our surroundings to make them predictable (correspondence), create a foundation with laws and theories that can generate more knowledge through deduction (coherence), and find ways to make use of this knowledge(pragmatic). This leads to scientific knowledge, which might not necessarily be the way things actually are? Why does gravity exist? What explains this attraction between two masses? As Mr. Cross would say, "It just is. Live with it”. Perhaps the manner in which we perceive this phenomena has been the very cause of this problem. The law of gravitation, a simple equation, created the concept of gravity. Gravity is not a phenomena, it's not a thing, it is just a description of the behavior of objects which allows us to predict and quantify exactly how they will move. If all of science works like that, if electromagnetism is just a description and not a thing that actually happens, science works a lot like math. It’s excellent in making predictions and categorizations, but it isn’t what nature is. However, gravity does pass the three scientific truth tests and is the basis of a lot of our understanding of the universe. Thus, to an extent, besides using reason, language (for communication and categorization, which could have an impact on the way we perceive certain things), imagination (to picture our models and representations), perception (for observations), memory, much like math science also relies on faith. Faith that what we have/know is what “it" is. 

This podcast from NPR, offers an interesting example (from 14:48, although I strongly recommend listening to the entire thing). Many theoretical physicists believe that science will reach a point where everything that is anything will be understood by humans, or their computers. But if multiple universes besides ours were to exist, the entire focus of science would have been just wrong. All of our constants, laws, and theories would have only explained how things work on our universe without considering what patterns might rule the other ones. They used an interesting analogy. Kepler dedicated a lot of his studies trying to explain why the earth was 93 million miles away from the sun. Why? Why 93 million? Is there an equation, or law that can explain this value? But once we start realizing that there are stars, nebulas, planets, and whatever else we can imagine, tens, hundreds, thousands, and millions of millions of miles away from the sun, the number 93 million becomes “arbitrary”. We thus shift our focus from the 93 million to the relative distances between Earth and Jupiter, our sun and Betelgeuse, the Milky Way and Andromeda, gaining knowledge on gravity, orbits, ellipses, and more. By gaining awareness of these other bodies around us, we gain a much larger perspective and can finally start asking the right questions. If many universes were to exist, all that we know would perhaps not be enough to explain “everything”. But just as scientists have done in the past, when revolutions such as the discovery of oxygen, relativity, quantum physics, and Galileo observations shattered all its previous beliefs, they adjust and start over. Change (once the current system has been proven false) and improvement are the very foundations of scientific knowledge, for science’s quest to explain everything is infinite. This could point an answer to our question, making “progressive” one of science’s mission statements. Its willingness to change and adapt to better, more efficient or precise forms of classification (the definition of "better" could be further analyzed) makes this way of knowing something modern and innovative, thus, progressive. However, “switching things around” undoes a lot of progress and can make things very uncomfortable for scientists, thus, theories that seek to explain perceived “anomalies" must endure tests, observations, and close analysis in order to be recognized by the scientific community. And this is great, for it ensures the validity of such “discoveries”. Due to this long, tiresome process, the paradigms established by science are often believed to be very, very accurate, which then explains why new theories which threaten this set of “beliefs” are so closely analyzed. It works as a continuous cycle, but does not hinder real advance or revolution. Drawing the line between science, the study of the physical  world through observation and experiment, and the actual physical and natural world is also important. Science is progressive in its way of perceiving the universe and drawing patterns to simplify what we see. That does not necessarily mean its area of study is progressive. I’m not sure if there is any way to find out. Could it be that science, just like math, is just really good at establishing patterns and successfully predict events around us in a totally random, wild, unsystematic reality?

If we were to consider things in practical terms, whether science accurately describes the natural world is not as relevant as its potential to improve our lives. It has allowed us to cure various diseases, learn more about our bodies, use nature to our advantage (solar power, wind power, electromagnetism), and more. But once humans get involved, we start adding more factors into question, such as emotion, consciousness, and ethics. One problem scientific developments in the sector of health is the ethics of stem cell research. This sector has enormous potential to revolutionize our lives, but has been deemed by many as unethical due to its experimentation on “life”. This leads us to a question that not even science can fully explain. Where and when does life begin? Is a fertilized egg a “life”? It’s definitely alive, but to what extent would it be wrong to kill and experiment with it? When scientific development faces these issues, its “progressiveness" can be put into question, for although the word has a positive connotation, it can pose threats to our notions of “humanity”. The pros and cons of this can be extensively debated.

And then we face another problem. Until when can something be progressive? Shouldn’t something gradually evolving, gradually changing reach its final form and… stop? Assuming there our universe is all there is, will we reach a point where we have categorized and explained (in our own terms) everything there is to know? What would happen then? Would we start reshuffling our periodic tables, equations, and taxonomies to find another way to build this jigsaw puzzle? Or would this state of progressiveness extend until infinity?

Sorry for the long post. 

Is Science Progressive?


            The answer to this question, like science if not set in stone. First we should analyze what progressive mean since the term is subject to interpretation. Because it isn’t simple to reach a conclusion on what a word might mean, I will use one of its denotations only for the blog. Thus, I will have to take into account that I have purposefully neglected other interpretations when I reach a conclusion. The definition will be the one where progressive means something that developing gradually. Of course there could also be a discussion of what the term science means but I won’t get into that since for the purpose of this question the common definition (the area of knowledge) is sufficient.
            To reach a conclusion on whether science is progressive or not, I took into consideration many aspects of science. Like math, we can think divide science into pure or applied science, which include biology or medicine (respectively). Though both are different they are connected to each other and seem to be changing constantly. When analyzing Popper’s Falsifiability, one of the key aspects was that a scientific theory is only considered one through its refutability. This means that a “real” scientific theory must have a chance of being proven wrong. When reading it, the concept shows how we are able to determine whether something is a scientific theory or not and this shows that something that once was considered a scientific knowledge can be “revoked” from that category if falsifiability test is made. Thus showing that what science is can be under constant change.
            Kuhn’s theory of scientific revolution exemplifies the progressivity of science very well by explaining what he describes as crisis period. During such new methods and approaches are tried since the older ones have been refuted. Does this necessarily mean that these theories are better? No. As Kuhn himself believed, science is not static and the changes that occur in the field might not always be any better than the theories before, however they do change. For that reason, if we take into consideration how “progressive” was defined, according to Kuhn’s theory it is because in both the definition for the word and his theory the “better” is not mentioned at all.
            Of course these two theories are not all that is taken into account when deciding whether science is progressive or not but there are several “real life” examples that point to such answer. For example, the explanation for combustion before there was the knowledge of what oxygen is. It included a substance (widely accepted in the 18th century) that was known as "phlogiston.” This substance was supposedly emitted during the burning of a certain material.  The modern theory explains the same phenomena through the oxygen theory and attributes that to the taking-in of oxygen, not the expulsion of the non-existent "phlogiston". Another great example of how pure science can be progressive can be seen in the classification chapter. In it the method of classification used in biology and developed by Carl Linnaeus in 1730 is shown to have changes. The taxonomy up until its 10th edition listed whales under fish but now it is known that whales are mammals. This change in classification is a result of progressivity (which happened throughout the 35 years that Linnaeus worked on the taxonomy and happens until this day with other scientists. The progress is still not over and possibly will never be, nowadays however, the modification happens through the use of nucleotide sequencing, which is a new tool that serves as an extended perception.
            These examples clearly show how pure science can be progressive but applied sciences are not excluded form the frame. Recently, a trial showed that a patient with myeloma (bone marrow cancer) had her tumor significantly decreased when treated with high doses of a genetically engineered measles virus. The disease was perfectly suited for the treatment since it normally affects the bone marrow, and when modified it carried an extra gene (of the thyroid) which together contributed to the patient’s (almost) cure from the disease. This example can relate a lot to the concept of when vaccines were created. At the time it seemed like a crazy idea to inject people with low doses of a virus to become immune to it. Likewise, it seems unrealistic to believe that inserting a great dose (more than billions of what a vaccine would carry) of a virus could actually help with the cure of a disease that was thought of incurable before. This example shows a good change, therefore a progress for the better of the applied sciences. This shift in paradigm is also stated in Kuhn’s theory.

            Like in science, empirical evidence was need for me to reach a conclusion regarding the progressivity of science and looking through the researches mentioned, enough was provided for me to conclude that science is indeed progressive. Taking into consideration, of course, the definitions of progressiveness and the common concept of science. Thus, with regards to how the terms were defined in the beginning of the blog post, I do believe science is constantly changing.

Monday, May 19, 2014

Science: Creation or Destruction?

The way I see science is that it helps us in our everyday lives. We are surrounded by science everyday within everything that we do. We could even say that human beings are science as we are something that scientists still study and are trying to figure out.
To create all the things that surround us and that we have access to in our everyday lives, science had to be used. Not only was science needed to understand how to create a certain thing but it was also needed to know which things could combine well with another. For example for biological classification, grouped certain organisms according to physical characteristics, which then made it easier for us to understand which two things had similarities or differences. Classification is still often times used today in the sense that it helps us organise what we know and don't know in order to progress on what we don't.

As we create things in our lives and try to improve things using science for example medicine. Everyday thanks to science there is improvement on finding cures for diseases.  This is an area when we as human beings rely on science greatly because without it we wouldn't be able to move forward and progress. But can't we ask ourselves, aren't those diseases there because of science?
The way that diseases come to being is still a question that we are trying to answer today because if we knew it would be a lot easier for us to find cures. But we do know that as the world evolves new diseases are created and contaminate certain people. This is why we are constantly trying to find cures for the diseases that didn't exists a few years ago. So as science evolves, diseases evolve? As we create new things using science we also create things that we weren't necessarily looking for. As an example, pollution. How did all the chemicals and gases get into the pure air that once dominated the planet. Science progression is probably the number one reason. As we create paper, we cut down trees, as we create products, factories burn gases into the air. Even as we drive or take the plan somewhere we emit chemicals to pollute the air. An argument could be that now with science we are trying to come up with the same things but that will minimise the amount of pollution released in the air. However will the solutions come fast enough?

Karl Popper looked at science in a different way. He looked at it as when you have a theory that cannot be proven to be true you can always look at it and falsify it. He would test scientific hypothesis and see if they could not be proven true if they could be proven wrong. Science always looks at things and tries to see if they are true but he looked at it differently. Scientists try to prove things to be true for the advancement in knowledge. If something is proven to be wrong then they come up with a new theory and it replaces it with constant testing. This cycle repeats until they have finally found a positive outcome. Some things that scientists research will never have a concrete answer or even won't affect us or improve the world of science in any way. So why bother? Why do we research things that won't help us find out other things?
Maybe because of our schema. We constantly are trying to discover new things because we are thirsty for knowledge. We want to be able create patterns and tie certain things we discovered to others. We want to be able to create relationships between why a certain thing is one way and why another is another way and to do so  we want to have as many proofs and scientific knowledge as we can. Our schema also helps us to understand the world and how the environment is rapidly changing. We can use theses schemas to understand what need to find out for the future and what will be helpful.

As science evolves it allows society and the world to evolve. There are many different theories that influence us and our way of thinking. Even our schema plays part in the way that science develops. From what I have learned in science so far, we are constantly discovering new things. For example the periodic table in the past was not the one that we have today, as time passed we discovered new elements. Or even in physics and how we have many formulas and calculations to explain what goes on around us and we are constantly referring to something being "because of the laws of physics".  In conclusion I would say that I think that science is progressive and it helps us in our everyday lives.



Is Science Progressive?


Let’s think about this question, is science progressive? What does this mean? I guess we want to find out if science evolves in a way, adapts and changes? First off, it’s important to analyze the ability of us humans to even observe the truth behind this question. Its much more complex than we may think. Take the theory of relativity for example. Can we consider this to be have progressed over the years? In a way, not really because it was created and devised by Einstein in the early 1900’s but ever since, there haven’t been any true additions or adjustments made to this theory. However, this is a very biased way to analyze the question, after all there are various sections of science with numerous theories and experiments. It is impossible to generalize because they could range from theoretical, physical, natural, medicinal etc. So where do we start? I would say from the clearest examples to prove the question as yes. Take modern medicine for example. There have been significant progresses and evolutions to this area. It is out of question to say that it has not changed since medieval medicinal practices for example. From leeches, we now treat patients with unimaginable amounts of medicine, vaccines, and antibiotics. Medicine is a very interesting aspect of science though, because it falls plainly into the practical science area. All discoveries and experiments are made to advance the science and be put into a practical use, to cure or treat certain ailments. Then we need to move on to the much more ambiguous section of “the sciences.” Let’s take theoretical sciences, such as physics. It is impossibly harder to quantify or find the truth behind advancements of theoretical physics. This is due entirely to its nature of being metaphysical, or talking about that which we cannot necessarily see or put to practical use. Any new knowledge or discoveries can only be classified as theories, and not completely true. So to what extent is this science ever progressing. How often do we hear of new findings in relation to theoretical physics? We could very well be biased because the science is very advanced and it is not as easy to make a breakthrough, but the more logical reason is due to the paradigms formed behind these sciences. According to Kuhn’s theory of scientific revolution, there are certain paradigms created that essentially underline a set of beliefs that a certain area of science believes in and bases its discoveries. Each scientist is contributing to add one more vital piece of the puzzle. It is this concept that causes so much controversy and is essential to this question. Scientists spend millions of dollars, time and resources to make new discoveries, however small they may be. And when a new theory comes out, many times it can potentially restructure and destroy that whole paradigm as they know it. Because of this, it may be hard for new theories to be considered truths. Nobody wants their work to be invalidated and have to completely start again. So to what extent is it easy for someone to contribute to the theoretical physics scientific community, and then further, how much has this science truly progressed. And what is the practicality of it. If extensive amounts of research are used only for these means, what is the point if modern science is not advanced enough to make any substantial discoveries. This is where the question: is science progressive gets truly foggy and confusing. Furthermore, there are more aspects that cause this science to be incredibly hard to progress. Let’s take Popper’s concept of falsifiability. It is nowadays; a theory considered true by the scientific community that for a scientific discovery to be true, it must be falsifiable (i.e. can be proved wrong or have areas of uncertainty). In a way, this theory somewhat disproves or contradicts what most of us believe to be the foundations of science. Science should be a study that is certain and always have a basis on facts. However, the very reality of theories having uncertainty or space to be shown false is what makes it true or viable. This adds unimaginable amounts of confusion to the creation of a scientific discovery in any type of area. How false can a theory be? Is modern technology advanced enough to successfully make contributions to the scientific community? Take the hadron collider for example. Are we ahead of our time? Should we even be experimenting with these things. And even if it can successfully make it work, how will we ever be able to test if the theory is speculation or a scientific truth? These are the questions that puzzle scientists in modern day. There are many proofs that can lean the question to either way. But if we consider the practicality of society and if we ever want to arrive to the answer of any question, let us take the most sensible path, and in this case I would have to say that science is in fact progressive, given the huge discoveries and advancements made in many areas of modern science.

Is Science Progressive?

Is Science Progressive?


Renato Curiati 


According to the Oxford Dictionary, the word “progressive” means, “happening or

developing gradually or in stages; proceeding step by step”. So is science

considered to be progressive? And to what extent is “step by step”? Until what
step is it considered progressive? All of these questions should be taken into
consideration, since different people will have different opinions on the big
question. In contrast to other subjects like philosophy, religion, art,
politics, among others, there are clear standards and criteria for identifying
improvements and advances in science. Normally, it is present once technology
has improved. Once this happens, then it becomes clear that science has
evolved. An evolvement may be as simple as a new tool, and also complex like
for example a cure for a disease. The important thing to notice is that any
advance in technology is a progression in science, and each person will
determine it according to his/her own schema.  


If we take Popper’s Falsifiability (falsifiability is to prove a statement to be false), he stresses the problem of demarcation (which is distinguishing the scientific from the unscientific). He states that demarcation is unscientific. But on the other hand, Kuhn challenged this idea of progress in “normal science”. With these two in mind, it is clear that there is a progression in science. Although one might argue that science is not progressive, scientists change their ideas, theories, methods, research, and so on. This change in technology and method demonstrates how science evolves as time goes by. Popper states one theory, and Kuhn another. Even though they disagree among themselves, it is this disagreement that shows that science is progressing. This whole debate is a positive thing because it advances science, and opens up a wide range of different research and theories. Every time science improves, it progresses.

According to the TOK Book, a good scientific theory should incorporate scientific laws and make existential or factual claim. Both philosophers have this in their theories. They incorporate the key elements for a strong scientific theory.


Another example of my own specific knowledge and a contemporary issue is the treatment

against AIDS. In the past, there were a huge number of deaths from people who
got the disease, and it was seen as incurable. But now technology has evolved,
and there is now a cure for AIDS, even though it is not 100% effective. Brazil
is known to have one of the best AIDS program in the world, which demonstrates
how science has progressed, and this is due to the increase in technology. Science
is evolving. What was once seen as impossible to achieve is now achievable.



            

Is science progressive?

When something is meant to be progressive, it means that it happens gradually or in
stages (step by step). In overall, science is progressive, as different
technological advances through time have brought new discoveries for the
scientific world. Something to keep in mind about this claim is that this is an
overall claim about scientific activities. It does not, whatsoever, imply that
each step in science has been progressive, since individual scientists make
mistakes and the scientific community is fallible in its collective and union judgments.

What also prevents this statement of being 100 percent true has to do with Popper’s falsifiability.
Falsifiability has to do with the inherent possibility of proving something
false. Popper imposes this idea that what is unfalsifiable is unscientific, and
what is falsifiable is scientific. He believed that the practice of declaring this
unfalsifiabilty to be true. A scientist might prove something to be false
without doing certain experiments, thus, making the claim that science is
progressive false.

However, just like Kuhn’s theory of scientific revolution did, Kuhn challenged the
prevailing view of progress in “normal science”. He believes that the normal
scientific progress is developed through the accumulation of facts and
theories. These discoveries made during revolutions leads to new a paradigm,
which then asks new questions of the old data, coming then to a conclusion. If
you think about it, Kuhn contradicted himself, since these discoveries were
made in a progressive manner. First, through accumulation, scientists find new
discoveries out, then forcing them to ask questions and qualify their data. In other
words, these discoveries do go through a progressive manner, where there are
lots of steps to prove claims.

The book claims that some discoveries were made “unpurposely”, meaning that these were
brought up unintentionally. To some extent, this is true, as we can see in the
solid models in Physics. It created a structure that, in som way, provided a
clear diagram of how electrons moved in a solid. However, it did not prove the
total point. It was only used to make the understanding more clear. Even though
it was made unintentionally, it did occur progressively. Scientists had to
gather enough information in a progressive manner to create this model. If it
was not done progressively, then this structure would not be credible as it now
is.

A classical example that also proves this claim is that natural science has been used to
describe the natural world through the use of scientific methods. Previously,
scientists did not have the adequate technology to prove all claims regarding
natural science. However, they did manage to use their available technology at
that time, and were, limitlessly, able to prove their point. In nowadays,
Physics, Biology, and Chemistry manage to find new scientific scientists, and
these scientists are now able to develop scientific experiments each and every
year to prove their points. In early, years, these same scientists were not
able to perform experiments to totally prove their points.

The final example that proves this claim has to do with a modern controversial issue:
global warming. There has been a discussion whether global warming actually
exists. However, this is not important for the claim. What really matters about
this controversial issue is that the information has been gathered from past
years. With new information being brought up, new discoveries and claims were
made. Thus, showing a progressive manner. In previous years, the claim that
global warming exists was not backed up sufficiently. However, as we can see in
the present moment, there is a lot to prove that global warming actually
exists. Even though it is controversial with huge debates going on, there is
nothing to against that this issue has been growing progressively, and in the
next few years, we can’t predict what types of claims will be made.

In other words, even though the normal scientific progress is viewed by Kuhn to be
non-progressive, it is true that scientific progress is progressive. In the
next few years, we cannot predict what technological advances will be made, and
this is part of the valid statement above. 

Wednesday, May 14, 2014

Your last post requires you to synthesize material, as always, but I want you to cover a few things in particular as you put the material together in your own way. You must include the following concepts and ideas in your response:

Popper's Falsifiability
Kuhn's theory of scientific revolution 
one idea from your textbook chapter on classification
schema 
one example from your own scientific knowledge 
one real world contemporary issue

Beyond that, you can approach the prompt however you want and include whatever ideas, arguments, and examples you choose. 


Is Science Progressive?